2. Bake a Cake (or something)
If you choose to make baked goods, put them in a bag or box and package them up nicely. (Think lots of hearts.)
For the dinner route, set the table, maybe light some candles and use a tablecloth, just go all out.
Remember, even if your attempt turns out to be a complete failure, you’ll always have something to share and laugh about as the years go by.